In the last week I saw ‘Shutter Island’ and read ‘The Kite Runner’. Both followed a similar trajectory: I was drawn in and hooked by the story, was subsequently disappointed by the all-too-perfectly-resolved ending, and then ultimately satisfied by narrative twists at the last minute (or page). I still think the resolution of the ‘Kite Runner’ plot is too poetically perfect for my tastes. It was gripping until the narrative grew less believable with each twist and revelation. Still good though, and saved by a less-than-perfect ending.
‘Shutter Island’ is growing on me. As I think back over the movie I admire how subtle the foreshadowing was and how the ‘disappointing’ ending actually set me up for a deliciously ambiguous final moment.
My hat’s off to you, director of ‘Shutter Island’. My hat has unfortunately been placed back on my head for you, author of ‘The Kite Runner’.